For 13 years, big red letters spelling "COFFEE" on a white background sat on an old building across the tracks from the downtown Libertyville Metra station. The front still has three garage doors, left over from the electrical contracting business that used the building before the espresso machines arrived.
Hansa Coffee Roasters closed that cafe at the end of September. Within three weeks, the Village's Appearance Review Commission had a new application for the same address, 755 N. Milwaukee Ave. It names a new tenant, Wild Oak Coffee Co.
In 2013, opening a coffee shop in that building was a bet. Now a second coffee business has lined up to move in, while the first one looks for another spot in town.
What the building was in 2013
When Hansa opened on Milwaukee Avenue in October 2013, Libertyville was a "coffee desert," owner Kevin Kane told the Daily Herald. The paper called Hansa one of the first places in town to offer a range of custom brews, and a spot to sit, talk, or watch the trains go by.
The name comes from the Hanseatic League, the northern European trading network that started in the 12th century. Hansa's own telling stresses relationships and trust more than ships and trade routes. In practice, that meant buying coffee through producers, importers, and cooperatives, and serving it with pastries made from scratch.
Kane described the community side of the shop in the same Daily Herald story. "I call it the 'Cheers' effect," he said, and added, "Coffee shops create and change communities."
How the Libertyville cafe closed
The Daily Herald reported that the lease wasn't renewed. On a Sunday evening in late September, about 100 regulars came by for two hours to share memories and have one last cup. By Monday morning, the space was mostly cleared out.
Patch followed up on September 30 and confirmed the closing. It also confirmed that the roasting operation had already moved out, while the Lake Bluff cafe and online orders stayed open.
That detail matters. The Libertyville cafe closed. Hansa did not.
What the Village file shows for 755 N. Milwaukee
Wild Oak Coffee Co.'s application went to the Appearance Review Commission on Monday, October 19. The Village's staff memo, dated October 15, lists Wild Oak as the tenant and Wami LLC as the property owner. The request is for new building facades, and the staff recommended approval.
The plan includes an outdoor patio, so the memo spends some time on it. The Village staff memo says the patio would need a permanent outdoor dining permit under the zoning code. They also asked the applicant to clear up a few points:
- What kind of lighting the patio would use.
- Whether the lighting under the existing "Coffee" sign would stay.
- Whether the applicant wanted text on the awning valance, which staff said could be up to 8 inches tall.
The second question is about the same sign the Daily Herald described in its first sentence about Hansa. The memo shows that the sign is part of the plan for the building's next chapter. Whether its lighting stays is still an open question.
Staff also noted that the rendering in the submission looked AI-generated and might not match the real building. They wrote that more comments could come during building permit review if the plans and the actual conditions differ.
At the meeting, the Commission voted 5–0 to recommend that the Village Board approve the facades, with two conditions, according to the minutes in the October 27 Board of Trustees packet:
- The refuse container must be enclosed to meet the Village's screening rules.
- The Commission wants a greener paint color, closer to the rendering, and the Commission chairman must review it before anyone paints.
The application was on the Board's agenda for its Tuesday, October 27 meeting, under the Commission's report. The Village records cover the facade and patio steps only. They don't include an opening date for Wild Oak, so watch for permit work and paint at the building.
Hansa's next Libertyville address
Hansa hasn't announced a new spot yet, but Kane made his plans clear. "I've been here for 26 years. I've been here longer than any other place I've ever been," he told the Daily Herald. "So my intention is to stay here and open up a cafe here." He and his wife, Janet, are looking, but they won't name a location until they have a deal.
He also said the business doesn't depend on the building. "It's not the space, it's the people who work here," Kane said in the same story. "Whatever space we're in, we'll bring the same coffee (and the) same level of customer service."
Until then, Hansa's nearest cafe is in Lake Bluff at 24 E. Scranton Ave., and online ordering is still available.
Libertyville's independent coffee map this fall
In 2013, Kane called Libertyville a coffee desert. Three independent shops in town are open now, and two more names are waiting on a new address or an opening:
| Shop | Address | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Conscious Cup Coffee Roasters | 355 N. Milwaukee Ave. | Roaster with a Libertyville cafe; hours are posted on its store page |
| Brewhaus Coffee | 107 E. Cook Ave. | Open; downtown on Cook Avenue |
| Tala Coffee Roasters | 834 Liberty Dr. | Also has locations in Highwood and Winnetka, per the Daily Herald |
| Hansa Coffee Roasters | 24 E. Scranton Ave., Lake Bluff | Hansa's nearest open cafe while it looks for a Libertyville spot |
| Wild Oak Coffee Co. | 755 N. Milwaukee Ave. | Facade and patio plans under Village review; no opening date announced |
The building across from the station has a coffee shop lined up as its next tenant. The Village is still waiting to hear what happens to the lighting under its "COFFEE" sign.
Two downtown dates in November
The next chance to see downtown at its busiest is First Fridays, which MainStreet Libertyville runs on Friday, November 6, from 5 to 9 p.m. Shops stay open late with refreshments and discounts. The next First Fridays is on December 4.
Small Business Saturday is on November 28, from 10 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. MainStreet is inviting shoppers downtown for deals from participating shops.
When a downtown storefront changes hands, homeowners nearby often start wondering what the block will look like in a year, and what that could mean for their own address. If you live near the Metra or the Milwaukee Avenue corridor and want to know where your home stands as these spaces turn over, Dana Pierson-Emering is happy to talk it through over coffee, wherever it ends up being served. Let's connect. Start your search or get a personalized home valuation.